Sign in to see full price history · a free account opens the chart and every recorded sale

1958 Topps Willie Mays All Star 486 · PSA 4 card image

#486 Willie Mays All Star price guide

Courtyard Notes

#486 Willie Mays All Star

1958 Topps · Baseball

KEY FACTS

Grade
PSA 4
Set
1958 Topps
Category
Baseball
Recorded sales (1y)
57

SOURCES

  • Courtyard sales data

PSA 4 VG-EX · 1958 Topps · Baseball

PSA 4 · Courtyard price

$136

▼ 3.7% 30d

Value by grade

That’s $74.80 more than a PSA 3.5, and $7.50 more than a PSA 3.

Typical range$105–$146
Last sale$113
Sales (1y)57

Listings aren’t shown in the Price Guide.

PSA 4 price history

57 recorded sales in the past year

See full price history

Create a free account to see this card's sales history.

PSA 4 sales

Latest 10 of 169 recorded sales · sign in for all

DatePriceSource
$113eBay
$145eBay
$143eBay
$144PWCC
$147eBay
$195eBay
$154eBay
$146eBay
$144PWCC
$175eBay
Sign in to see all 169 PSA 4 sales

How we price this card

#486 Willie Mays All Star is a card from 1958 Topps in Courtyard's Baseball price guide. Courtyard has recorded sales in the past year for 24 grades of this card. The most recent recorded sale was Nov 13, 2026 for PSA 3 at $125.

Graded copies are priced separately because condition drives value: a PSA 10 or BGS 9.5 usually sells for several times an ungraded copy. When a grade has no current value, it shows a sales-based estimate if Courtyard's data has one (the median of that grade's most recent dated, sourced sales, at least two and up to five), the sale itself if the grade's only dated sale is sourced, and otherwise marks the price unavailable. A grade is listed only when Courtyard has a recorded sale for it. Courtyard prices are estimates, not offers. Value source: Card price estimates.

Every grade, in detail
  • PSA 1: Courtyard price $63.50; 11 sales in the past year, median $54.99, ranging $31.20–$80.00.
  • PSA 1.5: Courtyard price $72.00; 3 sales in the past year, median $55.00, ranging $50.00–$80.00.
  • PSA 2: Courtyard price $89.70; 15 sales in the past year, median $59.95, ranging $45.00–$102.
  • PSA 2.5: Courtyard price $70.77; 3 sales in the past year, median $70.77, ranging $65.00–$105.
  • PSA 3: Courtyard price $128; 46 sales in the past year, median $92.25, ranging $51.00–$200.
  • PSA 3.5: Estimate $61.00, based on 5 sales, Mar 15, 2024 – Jan 21, 2025; 0 sales in the past year.
  • PSA 4: Courtyard price $136; 57 sales in the past year, median $125, ranging $63.62–$260.
  • PSA 4.5: Courtyard price $109; 4 sales in the past year, median $109, ranging $70.00–$149.
  • PSA 5: Courtyard price $208; 42 sales in the past year, median $181, ranging $110–$299.
  • PSA 5.5: Last sold $180 on Jun 18, 2025; 0 sales in the past year.
  • PSA 6: Courtyard price $327; 28 sales in the past year, median $257, ranging $187–$450.
  • PSA 7: Courtyard price $559; 15 sales in the past year, median $500, ranging $148–$685.
  • PSA 8: Courtyard price $1,354; 2 sales in the past year, median $1,354, ranging $1,350–$1,358.
  • BGS 4.5: Estimate $94.63, based on 2 sales, Jan 26, 2024 – May 7, 2024; 0 sales in the past year.
  • BGS 5: Estimate $104, based on 4 sales, Dec 27, 2023 – Dec 25, 2024; 0 sales in the past year.
  • BGS 5.5: Last sold $85.00 on Oct 1, 2025; 0 sales in the past year.
  • BGS 6: Courtyard price $300; 1 sale in the past year, median $300, ranging $300.
  • BGS 6.5: Courtyard price $250; 2 sales in the past year, median $250, ranging $249–$250.
  • BGS 7: Courtyard price $450; 1 sale in the past year, median $450, ranging $450.
  • CGC 3: Courtyard price $90.20; 4 sales in the past year, median $90.20, ranging $64.80–$121.
  • CGC 4.5: Courtyard price $103; 2 sales in the past year, median $103, ranging $88.80–$117.
  • CGC 6: Last sold $124 on Oct 2, 2025; 0 sales in the past year.
  • SGC 1: Courtyard price $53.00; 1 sale in the past year, median $69.00, ranging $69.00.
  • SGC 2: Courtyard price $76.00; 1 sale in the past year, median $76.00, ranging $76.00.
  • SGC 3: Courtyard price $96.90; 4 sales in the past year, median $92.50, ranging $72.00–$135.
  • SGC 4: Courtyard price $114; 6 sales in the past year, median $130, ranging $115–$185.
  • SGC 4.5: Courtyard price $102; 2 sales in the past year, median $95.00, ranging $90.00–$100.
  • SGC 5: Courtyard price $210; 3 sales in the past year, median $210, ranging $111–$248.
  • SGC 6: Courtyard price $162; 1 sale in the past year, median $240, ranging $240.
  • SGC 6.5: Courtyard price $326; 2 sales in the past year, median $326, ranging $300–$351.
See all grades
GradePriceRangeLast saleSales (1Y)
PSA 8$1,354$1,350–$1,358$1,3582
PSA 7$559$148–$685$49315
BGS 6.5$250$249–$250$2502
PSA 6$327$187–$450$32528
PSA 5.5$180Last sold Jun 18, 2025—$1800
PSA 5$208$110–$299$20842
PSA 4.5$109$70.00–$149$1374
PSA 4$136$63.62–$260$11357
PSA 3.5Estimate $61.00based on 5 sales, Mar 15, 2024 – Jan 21, 2025—$51.890
PSA 3$128$51.00–$200$12546
PSA 2.5$70.77$65.00–$105$1053
PSA 2$89.70$45.00–$102$99.9915
PSA 1.5$72.00$50.00–$80.00$80.003
PSA 1$63.50$31.20–$80.00$80.0011
Report a pricing issue

Let us know if something about this card’s pricing looks wrong.

10–1,000 characters, up to 2 links.
Only used if we need to follow up on this report.