Sign in to see full price history · a free account opens the chart and every recorded sale

#175 Christy Mathewson price guide
PSA 4.5 · 1940 Play Ball · Baseball
PSA 4.5 · Courtyard price
$409
Value by grade
That’s $84.50 more than a PSA 4, and $174 more than a PSA 3.
Listings aren’t shown in the Price Guide.
PSA 4.5 price history
3 recorded sales in the past year
Create a free account to see this card's sales history.
PSA 4.5 sales
Latest 7 of 7 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $495 | eBay | |
| $311 | eBay | |
| $409 | eBay | |
| $312 | PWCC | |
| $303 | eBay | |
| $238 | eBay | |
| $300 | eBay |
PSA 1 sales
Latest 9 of 9 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $136 | eBay | |
| $125 | eBay | |
| $125 | eBay | |
| $123 | eBay | |
| $140 | eBay | |
| $129 | eBay | |
| $129 | eBay | |
| $100 | eBay | |
| $103 | eBay |
PSA 1.5 sales
Latest 3 of 3 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $175 | eBay | |
| $135 | eBay | |
| $125 | eBay |
PSA 2 sales
Latest 6 of 6 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $105 | eBay | |
| $200 | eBay | |
| $212 | eBay | |
| $209 | eBay | |
| $220 | eBay | |
| $115 | eBay |
PSA 2.5 sales
Latest 1 of 1 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $129 | eBay |
PSA 3 sales
Latest 6 of 6 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $244 | eBay | |
| $226 | eBay | |
| $339 | eBay | |
| $135 | eBay | |
| $214 | eBay | |
| $209 | eBay |
PSA 4 sales
Latest 5 of 5 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $350 | eBay | |
| $299 | eBay | |
| $300 | eBay | |
| $225 | eBay | |
| $153 | eBay |
PSA 5 sales
Latest 9 of 9 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $517 | eBay | |
| $240 | eBay | |
| $299 | eBay | |
| $275 | eBay | |
| $550 | eBay | |
| $302 | eBay | |
| $302 | eBay | |
| $276 | eBay | |
| $275 | eBay |
PSA 6 sales
Latest 5 of 5 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $775 | eBay | |
| $500 | eBay | |
| $335 | eBay | |
| $480 | PWCC | |
| $389 | eBay |
PSA 7 sales
Latest 2 of 2 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $884 | eBay | |
| $330 | eBay |
PSA 7.5 sales
Latest 1 of 1 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $620 | eBay |
PSA 8 sales
Latest 1 of 1 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $610 | eBay |
CGC 1.5 sales
Latest 1 of 1 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $140 | eBay |
SGC 1.5 sales
Latest 1 of 1 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $120 | Cardhedger |
SGC 2 sales
Latest 1 of 1 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $99.00 | Cardhedger |
SGC 2.5 sales
Latest 1 of 1 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $170 | Cardhedger |
SGC 3 sales
Latest 3 of 3 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $130 | Cardhedger | |
| $225 | Cardhedger | |
| $179 | Cardhedger |
SGC 4 sales
Latest 1 of 1 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $400 | Cardhedger |
SGC 4.5 sales
Latest 3 of 3 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $176 | Cardhedger | |
| $220 | Cardhedger | |
| $181 | Cardhedger |
SGC 5 sales
Latest 1 of 1 recorded sales
| Date | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|
| $372 | Cardhedger |
How we price this card
#175 Christy Mathewson is a card from 1940 Play Ball in Courtyard's Baseball price guide. Courtyard has recorded sales in the past year for 9 grades of this card. The most recent recorded sale was Nov 3, 2026 for PSA 4.5 at $495.
Graded copies are priced separately because condition drives value: a PSA 10 or BGS 9.5 usually sells for several times an ungraded copy. When a grade has no current value, it shows a sales-based estimate if Courtyard's data has one (the median of that grade's most recent dated, sourced sales, at least two and up to five), the sale itself if the grade's only dated sale is sourced, and otherwise marks the price unavailable. A grade is listed only when Courtyard has a recorded sale for it. Courtyard prices are estimates, not offers. Value source: Card price estimates.
Every grade, in detail
- PSA 1: Courtyard price $136; 1 sale in the past year, median $136, ranging $136.
- PSA 1.5: Courtyard price $155; 2 sales in the past year, median $155, ranging $135–$175.
- PSA 2: Courtyard price $106; 1 sale in the past year, median $105, ranging $105.
- PSA 2.5: Last sold $129 on Jan 6, 2024; 0 sales in the past year.
- PSA 3: Courtyard price $235; 2 sales in the past year, median $235, ranging $226–$244.
- PSA 4: Courtyard price $325; 2 sales in the past year, median $325, ranging $299–$350.
- PSA 4.5: Courtyard price $409; 3 sales in the past year, median $409, ranging $311–$495.
- PSA 5: Courtyard price $517; 1 sale in the past year, median $517, ranging $517.
- PSA 6: Courtyard price $264; 3 sales in the past year, median $500, ranging $335–$775.
- PSA 7: Estimate $607, based on 2 sales, Sep 13, 2023 – Mar 6, 2024; 0 sales in the past year.
- PSA 7.5: Last sold $620 on Jan 18, 2024; 0 sales in the past year.
- PSA 8: Last sold $610 on Nov 1, 2023; 0 sales in the past year.
- CGC 1.5: Courtyard price $140; 1 sale in the past year, median $140, ranging $140.
- SGC 1.5: Last sold $120 on Feb 25, 2025; 0 sales in the past year.
- SGC 2: Last sold $99.00 on Jun 28, 2024; 0 sales in the past year.
- SGC 2.5: Last sold $170 on Mar 5, 2025; 0 sales in the past year.
- SGC 3: Estimate $179, based on 3 sales, Jan 15, 2024 – Nov 17, 2024; 0 sales in the past year.
- SGC 4: Last sold $400 on Jan 27, 2024; 0 sales in the past year.
- SGC 4.5: Estimate $181, based on 3 sales, Mar 6, 2024 – Aug 14, 2025; 0 sales in the past year.
- SGC 5: Last sold $372 on May 19, 2025; 0 sales in the past year.
See all grades
| Grade | Price | Range | Last sale | Sales (1Y) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PSA 8 | $610Last sold Nov 1, 2023 | — | $610 | 0 |
| PSA 7.5 | $620Last sold Jan 18, 2024 | — | $620 | 0 |
| PSA 7 | Estimate $607based on 2 sales, Sep 13, 2023 – Mar 6, 2024 | — | $884 | 0 |
| PSA 6 | $264 | $335–$775 | $775 | 3 |
| PSA 5 | $517 | $517 | $517 | 1 |
| PSA 4.5 | $409 | $311–$495 | $495 | 3 |
| PSA 4 | $325 | $299–$350 | $350 | 2 |
| PSA 3 | $235 | $226–$244 | $244 | 2 |
| PSA 2.5 | $129Last sold Jan 6, 2024 | — | $129 | 0 |
| PSA 2 | $106 | $105 | $105 | 1 |
| PSA 1.5 | $155 | $135–$175 | $175 | 2 |
| PSA 1 | $136 | $136 | $136 | 1 |
Report a pricing issue
Let us know if something about this card’s pricing looks wrong.